Top 16 Crib Mattress to buy in 2023

by babyfellow | Jan 25, 2020 | Crib Mattress

Our Favorites:

We are sharing our top four favorites crib mattresses below. The criteria were mainly related to the specs, price and customer ratings.

Moonlight Slumber Dual Sided Baby Crib Mattress:

• 92% happy customers out of 300 plus reviews
• Bed bug and dust mite resistant
• Price is on a higher side but you get the value of your money

Milliard Crib Mattress-Dual Comfort System:

• 92% happy customers
• Dual side mattress
• Certi-Pur certified
• Waterproof cover
• Low Price

Dourxi Crib Mattress:

• Money-back guarantee
• Airflow technology
• Reasonable price
• 90% happy customers

Imagio Baby Premium Dual Sided Crib Mattress

• Waterproof
• Manufacturing fault warranty
• 100% customer satisfaction
• Reasonable price

Is your baby safe while sleeping on a crib mattress??

Do you know about SIDS??

If we consider a baby having a comfortable sleep, the first quality we think is of a soft crib mattress, but extra soft mattress may cause SIDS (Sudden Infant death Syndrome). A death while sleeping, of a child less than one year of age.

Though this scenario still remains unexplained but as parents, we have to be careful while choosing a crib mattress. In this article, we have explained several qualities that will help you to buy the right product for your baby.

Our babies are the greatest gift from God and as they grow we see something new, amazing and cute on a daily basis. With all the joy comes a huge responsibility for parents to make the right decisions for their babies with the assurance of safety and comfort for the infants and toddlers.

One of the few products that new excited parents prefer to buy even before the birth of their baby is a crib and its mattress. While you finalize your decision, make sure your crib mattress fits all standards. There are few factors that needed to be considered before buying the mattress for the crib.

Choosing the right One:

Buying the best crib mattress for the baby is the main goal. It’s really important to know that mattress comes in 2 categories, soft and firm. The firm mattress is suitable for newborn babies whereas soft works well for the toddlers.

The Right Size

Size is really an important factor when it comes to buying a crib mattress, even the best mattresses are not useful if they are not the right fit for the crib, therefore, it is highly recommended to check and re-check the size of your crib and order the right mattress accordingly

Life of a mattress

Normally if used with care a mattress can work effectively for up to 3 years. We recommend going with a dual side mattress. It is firm from one side and soft from the other.

As explained earlier that soft side is for toddlers whereas the firm is more suitable for infants. Once your baby reaches to toddler age you can simply flip the mattress and it becomes a long-lasting crib mattress.

Easy to Clean:

It’s a universal truth that a baby can make a mess within a matter of no time, so we would recommend choosing the mattress which is easy to clean, there are some options having waterproof covers available to make your life easy.

Organic Support:

The concept is changing day by day and most of the parents are going with organic products. These products are backed by many medical professionals as well. The products made with non-organic materials might cause some health-related issues whereas organic mattresses provide a safe environment for the baby.

Certifications:

Certification is another criterion for a safe mattress. Normally you’ll see certifications like “Oeko-Tex Standard” which basically tells us that there is no usage of fire retardants and heavy material whereas is “Green guard” certifications ensure that no harmful emissions are used. GOTS (Global Organic Textile Standards)  status is given to mattresses made up of a minimum of 70% organic fibers.

How much is a mattress for a crib?

Normally a good quality mattress ranges from $70 to $200 there are some products available for 50 dollars as well. It all depends on your budget and the size of the crib you have.

We have shortlisted the top 16 crib mattresses on the basis of their specifications, quality, and the number of customer reviews. If a product has a big number of reviews and still able to maintain good rating score, is a clear indication of the mattress doing well in the market, however, every customer may have different experience from others, therefore it is suggested to keep your requirements in mind while finalizing any product to ensure a great experience for your baby.

1. Graco Premium Foam Crib Mattress:

The Graco brand has developed a great level of goodwill in the eyes of its users for quite some time. As far as this crib mattress is concerned, it looks to be of good quality and safe for the baby.

The first step as a buyer you need to take is to unroll the mattress within 2 weeks of delivery to get it used to the room temperature.

This mattress is Green Guard Gold certified, Lead and mercury-free, meets Federal flammability standards. It is composed of top-quality material with a combination of breathable foam which helps to maintain the air-flow and hence provide the safety factor for the young user.

The mattress comes with a Water-resistant cover which is recommended to hand-wash only.

Pros:

• Perfectly fits the normal size Crib
• Green Guard Gold Certified
• Meets Federal flammability standards
• Reasonable Price

Cons:

• Have few complaints of mattress not expanding fully and unable to reach the promised height of 5 Inches.

Customers’ Reviews:

The mattress has maintained a score of 4.5 out of 5 which is absolutely amazing considering the 4000 plus reviews. Overall 87% of the buyers are extremely satisfied with their decision whereas around 10% have some complaints, mostly related to not fully expanding however the positive feedback gives us totally an opposite view, they are happy with the expansion, quality and find it worth value of their money.

• Measurement: length (52 inches) x Width (27. 6 inches) x Height (up to 5 inches)
• Price on Amazon: 59.99 USD

2. Moonlight Slumber Dual Sided Crib Mattress:

The best thing about this crib mattress is its “Dual side sleep system” this means that one side is made a bit firm that suits the sleeping requirement of babies less than one year of age whereas the other side is softer and suits the toddlers.

The product has gone through some strong checks to ensure high performance and meeting the safety standards.

Pros:

• free of toxic flame-retardant chemicals
• extra tight sewn seams
• bed bug and dust mite resistant

Cons:

• Price is a bit on the higher side as compared to available competitors.
• Some complaints of Mattress sags in the middle after few months of use

Customer’s Reviews:

This product has got nearly 300 reviews so far, the happy customers are 92% which is great meanwhile 5% don’t look satisfied with their purchase. There are few complaints related to smell and mattress getting sagged. But when we look at the positive feedbacks which are 92% by the way, we see a lightweight, easy to clean and perfect to buy the product.

• Measurement:  27.5 x 5 x 52 inches
• Price: $196.99

3. Milliard Crib Mattress-Dual Comfort System:

The Milliard Crib Mattress also comes with a Dual side sleep system just like “Moonlight Slumber” however this mattress costs just $73 which is less than half of the price of the competitor, due to which it gets our preference.

The rich fabric layer of foam will ensure the safety of newborns whereas the other side made of softer foam will ensure a healthy sleep of a toddler.

The mattress cover can easily wipe away stains and the messes.

Pros:

• Memory foam helps in deep sleep
• CertiPUR-US certified polyurethane foam
• Porous foam layer allows the baby to breathe a bit easier
• The waterproof inner layer
• Includes a removable, waterproof cover to protect the crib mattress

Cons:

• Few complaints of being extra soft

Customers’ Reviews:

This Milliard mattress is also giving a tough time to its competitors and has maintained a 4.6 score out of 5 in around 1000 reviews, the satisfaction level stands at 92% with only 6% unhappy customers.

The unhappy customers found it extra soft and some have received the product with stains on it, on the other hand, the happy customers are satisfied with the quality, price, and comfort it provides.

• Measures: 52 x 27½ x 5.5 inches
• Price: $74.

4. Milliard Premium Baby Crib Mattress:

This crib mattress contains a durable Hypoallergenic Memory Foam base with a top layer of luxe memory foam that provides comfort without compromising the support.

The mattress is waterproof from top and sides and provides air ventilation with the assurance of safety.

The inner fiberglass lining meets the fire safety regulation standards.

Pros:

• CertiPUR-US certified
• Meets all fire safety regulations
• Free of chemicals and toxins.
• Allows air and heat ventilation

Cons:

• Might not remain waterproof after a few months of usage
• Few customers have complained about the chemical smell.

Customers’ Reviews:

This Millard crib mattress has got around 225 reviews with 89% positive and 9% negative feedback so far. The dissatisfied customers share a common opinion that the mattress is not waterproof, meanwhile, the majority have found it great, better than expected and durable.

• Measurement: 52″ x 27.5″ x 5.5″
• Price:$89.98

5. Newton Baby Crib Mattress:

This high priced product seems to justify the price with the features it offers. This crib mattress uses breath-thru technology that enables easy airflow, helps the intake of CO2 while sleeping and minimize the risk of suffocation.

Another exciting feature is its temperature control which helps in reducing sweaty back and ensures a peaceful sleep for the young user.

Pros:

• GREENGUARD GOLD CERTIFIED
• Family choice award in the year 2017
• 3D Space cover which is completely breathable and machine washable
• More breathable than its competitors
• Available in 4 colors

Cons:

• The price is on the higher side.
• Few complaints of plastic smell
• Waterproof layer not available in every product. Keep this factor in mind while placing your order

Customers’ Reviews:

Out of 500 plus reviews so far the score for this mattress is 4.7 out 5 which is really impressive, 92% of people are satisfied with their decision of going for Newton crib mattress whereas only 4% seems unhappy. Few common complaints are related to plastic smell and hard surface.

The Majority of the buyers, however, are satisfied and believe that the mattress is amazing and provides a comfortable sleep.

• Measurement: 52 x 28 x 5.5 inches
• Price: $299.99

6. Colgate Classica III Crib Mattress:

This mid-range crib mattress by Colgate also has dual firmness to fit the need of both infants and the toddlers. The installation of eyelets on the sides not only giving it a unique look but also provides the extra airflow.

The infant side offers extra support to make it as firm as recommended by most of the medical experts.

Pros:

• GREENGUARD GOLD CERTIFIED
• CertiPUR-US certified

Cons:

• It might be too firm for some.

Customers’ Reviews:

The overall reviews are great with 91% customer satisfaction out of 100 plus reviews whereas 6% are not happy, most of them found the mattress extra firm and hard, however, the satisfied customers found it lightweight, firm, safe and a high-quality product.

• Measurement: 52 x 27.8 x 6 inches
• Price: $145.99

7. Nap You Dual Comfort Crib Mattress

This crib mattress also offers dual side option,  one side is firm which is suitable for infants whereas the other is a bit softer for the toddlers. It also offers an extra layer of form to support the posture of the neck and back of the toddlers.

The mattress cover is made up of organic cotton blend and 100% water-proof and easy to clean which gives you a great amount of peace of mind

Pros:

• 100% WATERPROOF COVER
• CertiPUR-US certified
• Compatible to any washer & dryer
• Cover made with organic cotton

Customers’ Reviews:

There are 100 plus reviews out of which 88% are on the satisfactory and 6% on the negative side. The low ratings are given for various reasons, with no specific or repeated complain noted so far.

• Measurement: 52 x 27 1/2 x 5.5 inches
• Price: $119.99

8. Dourxi Crib and Toddler Mattress:

The Dourxi Crib mattress will be a bit compressed when reaches you but allow it around 72 hours to get expended properly and get adjusted to the environment. In most cases, it takes 24 hours only.

The mattress fits the crib perfectly and getting great overall feedback of the customers with respect to its quality, feel and comfort. The mattress is made by Polyurethane foam which provides the required firmness for the young user.

It uses the airflow technology that allows the smooth circulation of air to the baby.

It comes with an amazing offer of 100 days’ money-back which shows the confidence of the manufacturer in his creation. In addition, there is another 10-year warranty for any manufacturing fault which is an added advantage however it limits manufacturing faults only.

Pros:

• CertiPUR-US certified
• Foam punch design allows air to flow freely
• 100-day money-back guarantee
• 10-year manufacturing fault warranty

Cons:

• Few complaints of mattress not fully expanded and in some cases the expansion is un-even

Customers’ Reviews:

The score is 4.6 out of 5 with a 90% customer satisfaction level. Only 6% of the people have given it a lower rating. There are few complaints where mattresses didn’t expand as per the expectations of the customers however the manufacturer has given a 100-day money-back guarantee which is the best solution if you don’t like the mattress due to any reason.

• Measurement: 52 x 27½ x 5 inches
• Price: $89.99

9. Simmons Kids Slumber Crib Mattress:

This Simmons kids product is a dual-sided mattress with one side made up of foam core, blended with soy that provides the comfort for the infants whereas the other side contains an additional layer of foam to match the need of the toddlers.

The mattress cover is waterproof and made by cotton which is extremely easy to clean

Pros:

• Made by Non-Toxic Materials
• GREEN GUARD Gold certified:
• CertiPUR-US certified
• Waterproof mattress cover

Cons:

• There is a consistency noticed in customer’s feedback in two areas:
  • The mattress might be too firm
  • Complains of bad smell

Customers’ Reviews:

Out of around 150 ratings, the satisfactory level stands at around 82% which is a bit lower than most of the competitors,  the number of unhappy customers is also on the higher side with 14%. As mentioned in the cons area the complaints are related to extra firmness and bad smell.

Just like in the case of other mattresses the happy customers share a different story here as well. They found it great, perfect for the crib and more than what they expected for.

• Measurement: 27.5″W x 52″L x <6″H
• Price: $94.99

10. Delta Children Twinkle Stars Crib Mattress:

This crib mattress also offers a double side usage with a firm side for infants and soft side with one extra layer of foam to ensure the comfort of the toddlers

It contains 162 interlocking coils that make a steady foundation to help the user having an amazing sleeping session, In addition, the highly-dense polyester layers create a comfortable experience.

Pros:

• GREENGUARD Gold Certified
• CertiPUR-US certified
• Waterproof cover
• Toxic-free ingredients

Cons:

• Few complains of smell and feel of spring inside

Customers’ Reviews:

The customer reviews are heading towards 150-mark with 89% satisfaction and 7% dissatisfaction levels. There are minor complains of bad smell and springs poking the baby whereas most of the customers are loving the product.

• Measurement: 52″ x 27.5″ x <6″
• Price: $79.99

11. Kolcraft Pure Sleep Waterproof Crib Mattress:

This Kolcraft mattress is made up of 15 gauge steel coils to ensure the firmness of the product. The mattress cover is waterproof and its lock-stitched binding guards any moisture to go inside.

The product is made in the USA and fits most of standard size cribs and beds

Pros:

• Non-Toxin material
• GREENGUARD Gold Certified
• Water Proof cover
• Easy to clean

Cons:

• You may feel the springs inside the mattress
• Might become noisy after a few months
• Few Sagging complains

Customers’ Reviews:

This crib mattress is able to get only 80% of the customer’s positive feedback which is a bit on the lower side, and 14% unsatisfactory customer reviews, however, the number of customer reviews is around 450 which is defiantly higher than so many others.

• Measurement: 1.63” (Length) x 27.25’ (Width) x 5” (Height)
• Price: $63.00

12. Imagio Baby Premium Dual Sided Crib Mattress

The Imagio Baby crib mattress really got our attention because of the features it offers and also the customer ratings. The number of customers’ reviews are only 7 and it might be due to the novelty of this product but so far it has able to achieve the 100% customer satisfaction mark. So it is a product worth a consideration based on the performance so far.

The crib mattress uses breathable stuff to ensure the safety of the baby and meets all federal flammability standards. It has the feature of dual side usage with a firm side for infants and a soft side for toddlers.

The mattress may require around 48 hours to expand to its full potential. it is a water-resistant product

Pros:

• Oeko-TEX STANDARD 100 certified
• Uses CertiPUR-US foam products
• TPU waterproof protection
• Lifetime Product Warranty covers manufacturing faults

Cons:

• Not Green Guard Certified

Customers’ Reviews:

The number of reviews so far is on the lower which is around 15 however the good news is 100% customer satisfaction which is absolutely amazing.

• Measurement: 28 x 5 x 52 inches
• Price: $89.99

13. Signature Sleep Natural Wool Crib Mattress:

The material used in this crib mattress is certified organic cotton, chemical-free and unbreakable wool, and natural coconut coir which is something worthy of consideration while buying a crib mattress.

Pros:

• Made by the use of Organic materials
• OEKO-TEX certified
• Hand Made
• GOTS certified
• Higher Price

Cons:

• Not Green Guard Certified

Customers’ Reviews:

The customer reviews share kind of mix feelings reflected in 14 reviews so far. There are no 2 and 3-star ratings which is something not commonly observed however there is 01 feedback of 1-star level. On the positive side, 89% of buyers are happy with their choice.

• Mesurement: 52″ x 28″ with 4″ height
• Price: $269.00

14. Wonder Dream Dual Comfort Crib Mattress:

This product is unique with respect to the material used in its making. The company claims No foam usage instead it is made by food grade polymer which helps in free movement of the airflow and assures the safety of the young user.

It’s a dual side mattress with one side for toddler and other for infants. The cover is water repellent from top and sides, requires 72 hours to regain its shape

Pros:

• No PVC
• No Foam

Customers’ Reviews:

There are only 14 reviews so far with Mix of 4 and 5-star ratings which is a good start.

• Measurement: 52″ x 28″ x 5″.
• Price: $119.99

15. Safety 1st Crib and Toddler Bed Mattress:

This lightweight crib mattress is available in 2 classes; standard and supreme. It is made up of fiber core that provides good support in its durability.

The manufacturer has recommended rotating the mattress every 3 months to get the maximum performance out of it.

The mattress is available in 2 colors (Blue & white)

Pros:

• GREENGUARD GOLD Certification
• Waterproof cover sheet

Cons:

• There seems to be a durability issue with this crib mattress, a good number of customers have shared one problem that this mattress is not a long-lasting one and starts to tear apart after 3 to 6 months. This is a very alarming situation and must be kept in consideration.

Customers’ Reviews:

As far as ratings are concerned the number of customer ratings is 4000 plus which might be the highest or at least in the top 10 as far as number is concerned. For customer satisfaction the score is very low for this crib mattress, only 74% found it satisfactory whereas 20% has marked at below satisfactory level.

Even with the lower ratings the people still showing their interest in buying this specific mattress which might be due to its price which is only $55.

• Measurement: 52″L x 27.5″W x 5″H.
• Price: $55.92

16. Sealy Baby Posturepedic Crib Mattress:

This crib mattress was designed in consultation with the Orthopedic Advisory Board which comprised of professionals of the field. It has a heavy-duty form with lots of layers and a heavy adult grade coil installed in it which has the ability to sense the baby’s movement and adjust accordingly.

The cover is easily cleanable and waterproof, under the cover there is a protective cotton cushion followed by 3 layers to enhance the durability and ensuring comfort.

The product is designed to ensure the smooth natural airflow which is a good characteristic of the mattress.

Pros:

• GREENGUARD Gold Certified
• Two non-allergenic layers
• Company in business for around 130 years

Cons:

• Might get sagged after few months
• Few complains of being extra soft

Customers’ Reviews:

This heavy-duty crib mattress got 200 plus feedbacks of the customer and surprisingly the success rate it only 76% meanwhile around 18% of the buyers don’t look happy.

• Measurement: 51.63″ x 27.25″ x 5.75
• Price: $105.99

What is the best mattress for a baby crib?

As you must have noticed after reading this article that most of the mattresses have got 90% and above score in the customer reviews, it is also clear that even the best products have got some unhappy customers, therefore, now we can say that every person has his/her own requirements and expectations from a product based on which they decide whether it was good for them or was it a bad decision.

Conclusion:

It is always recommended to choose the one you like after reviewing the specification and the existing customer ratings. Repeated complains mean the issue really exists.

The safety of your baby must be the basic goal while choosing a mattress, the price and other factors should be considered as secondary issues.